Posted: 01/01/2024

Local Picks: Best Pizza in Lancaster, PA

For a slice of heaven in Lancaster.

What makes the perfect slice of pizza? Whether a thin, crispy crust topped with exotic toppings and fresh mozzarella or a thick, fluffy crust topped with cheese and classic pepperoni – Lancaster has the perfect slice.

We’ve rounded up the cheesiest, tastiest, and most unique pies to sink your teeth into. Check out some local picks that will satisfy your pizza cravings.


436 W James St, Lancaster
Liz says “I love the unique combos that you can find a Luca!” Andrew says “Luca’s pizza is out of this world. The pizza is baked in a Neapolitan wood-burning oven, and you can taste the love and care they put into each pie.” Luca appeared in the New York Times, who raved about their wood-fired appetizers, artisan cocktails, and handmade pasta that are featured alongside their tasty pizza.

Rosa Rosa Pizzeria

1040 Harrisburg Pk, Lancaster
Jess says "I love all the different types of pizzas you can get by the slice, among all the menu items and whole pizzas that are available!"

Your Place Restaurant & Pub

2133 Lincoln Highway East, Lancaster
Your Place Restaurant & Pub has been serving central PA since 1972. They are a family-owned establishment known for our traditional food, especially our World Famous Stromboli! Whether you’re alone or with a large group, we can accommodate any occasion at Your Place Restaurant & Pub.

Pasquale’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

1657 Old Philadelphia Pike, Lancaster
Pasquale's is a cozy restaurant perfect for casual or romantic dining. You can dine in, carry out or deliver to you! Their menu offers authentic Italian pasta, seafood, and chicken dishes as well as delicious subs and steak sandwiches, panini melts, fresh salads, and great pizza! Be sure to save room for dessert!

Lancaster Brewing Company

302 North Plum Street, Lancaster
Lancaster Brewing Company is a craft brewery and distillery located in the historic Edward McGovern Tobacco building, built in 1880. The brewery is staffed by an inspired collective of brewers, distillers, chefs, and service staff members who welcome the entire family. You can enjoy an excellent meal, award-winning craft brews and spirits, great company and create lasting memories at Lancaster Brewing Company.

DiMaria's Pizza

1183 Erbs Quarry Rd, Lititz
Katie says “I love Grandma Pizza from DiMaria’s in Lititz. It requires extra wait time when you order it, but it’s so worth it!”

Finazzo's Italian Restaurant & Pizza

2121 New Holland Pk, Lancaster
Sarah says "The crust is delightfully delicious, not too thick and not too thin!"

Parma Pizza

301 W Main St, Landisville
Nicole says “It's hard to pick just one! Our favorite local spot is Parma Pizza. We especially like the Holiday pizza which has spinach, broccoli, tomato, and ricotta- yum.”

Nino's Pizzeria & Ristorante

361 Comet Dr, Millersville
Samantha says "I love Nino's because they're very friendly and their chicken bacon ranch pizza is to die for."

Recommended For You

Foodie Towns in Lancaster, PA

Lancaster has more than PA Dutch cuisine. Enjoy international, fine dining and so much more!

Two blonde women sit at a table as one takes a drink from a glass during Lancaster City Restaurant Week in Lancaster, PA.

Where to go for outdoor dining in Lancaster County.

Group of friends sitting around a high-top table, cheersing glasses of beer, in a rustic bar setting.

Lancaster County has a wide variety of restaurants suitable for groups of all kinds.

Farm-to-Table cuisine is a way of life here, with homemade and hand-crafted delights filling tables and tummies.



436 W. Jame Street
Lancaster, PA 17603