Posted: 01/11/2022 | by Jessica

Local Picks: Best Pizza in Lancaster, PA

For a slice of heaven in Lancaster.

Local Picks: Best Pizza in Lancaster, PA

What makes the perfect slice of pizza? Whether it’s thin, crispy crust topped with exotic toppings and fresh mozzarella or thick, fluffy crust topped with cheese and classic pepperoni – Lancaster has the perfect slice for you.

We’ve rounded up the cheesiest, tastiest and most unique pies for you to sink your teeth into. Check out some local picks that will satisfy your pizza cravings.

LUCA | 436 W James St, Lancaster
Liz says “I love the unique combos that you can find a Luca!” Andrew says “Luca’s pizza is out of this world. The pizza is baked in a Neapolitan wood-burning oven, and you can taste the love and care they put into each pie.” Luca appeared in the New York Times, who raved about their wood-fire appetizers, artisan cocktails, and handmade pasta that are featured alongside their tasty pizza.

Pie to try: Piccante – crushed tomato, hot soppressata, mozzarella, pecorino, shaved garlic, hot honey

Rosa Rosa Pizzeria | 1040 Harrisburg Pk, Lancaster
Jess says "I love all the different types of pizzas you can get by the slice, among all the different menu items and whole pizzas that are available!"

Pie to try: Spaghetti Pizza - pizza crust with spaghetti filling

DiMaria's Pizza | 1183 Erbs Quarry Rd, Lititz
Katie says “I love Grandma Pizza from DiMaria’s in Lititz. It requires extra wait time when you order it, but it’s so worth it!”

Pie to try: Grandma Pizza – thin square pizza with chunk tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto, garlic & olive oil

Finazzo's Italian Restaurant & Pizza | 2121 New Holland Pk, Lancaster
Sarah says "The crust is delightfully delicious, not too thick and not too thin!"

Pie to try: Texas Steak Pizza - Philly steak, red onions, hot sauce, American & mozzarella cheese

Parma Pizza | 301 W Main St, Landisville
Nicole says “It's hard to pick just one! Our favorite local spot is Parma Pizza. We especially like the Holiday pizza which has spinach, broccoli, tomato, and ricotta- yum.”

Pie to try: Holiday Special – white pizza with fresh garlic, olive oil, tomatoes, broccoli, spinach, ricotta, mozzarella cheese

Nino's Pizzeria & Ristorante | 361 Comet Dr, Millersville
Samantha says "I love Nino's because they're very friendly and their chicken bacon ranch pizza is to die for."

Pie to try: Chicken Bacon Ranch - grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, and mozzarella cheese