posted May 03, 2024

Lancaster, PA’s Best Burger Spots

High quality local burgers hot off the grill!

Fewer things are better than a burger fresh off the grill. From the classic cheeseburger to one piled high with tasty toppings, this nostalgic sandwich conjures up memories of backyard barbeques and days at the diner. Here in Lancaster County, you can find restaurants inspired by the past, along with spots focused on today’s trending flavors– who are all flipping delicious burgers for you to try.

Cabalar Meat Co.
325 N Queen St, Lancaster
Cabalar is a unique eatery that combines the best of a butchery and a burger joint. Located in the heart of Lancaster, they offer a delicious selection of burgers, sandwiches, fries, and shakes, all made with high-quality ingredients. They are a family-run establishment, so they take pride in serving their customers only the best. There is also a great selection of craft beers and cocktails from Mad Chef Craft Brewery. Since 2018, their goal has been to create food that you'll want to rave about to your neighbors. So, come down to Cabalar with an open mind, an empty stomach, and stretchy pants to enjoy some tasty offerings.

Horse Inn
540 E Fulton St, Lancaster
At the Horse Inn, there’s only one burger on the menu – but trust us, it’s the only one you need. Locals love this burger and rightfully so. It’s custom blend of short rib, brisket, chuck & 10% dry aged beef makes for a tender, juicy and most importantly, flavorful burger that they top simply with lettuce, red onion, tomato, white American cheese and special sauce. The bun is made locally by Alfred & Sam’s and toasted to perfection. While you’re enjoying the burger paired with an artfully crafted cocktail, take in the speakeasy vibes of this restaurant that dates back to the 1920s.

BJ's Pit Stop Bar & Grill
3504 Old Philadelphia Pike, Intercourse
BJ's Pit Stop Bar & Grill is a laid-back, car-themed spot serving classic pub-style burgers you can load up with your favorite toppings. Burger options include the Pit Stop Burger, featuring your choice of cheese, tomato, red onion, and optional bacon; the Pantera Burger, stacked with pepperoni, provolone, and pizza sauce; and the Packard Burger, a Kobe beef burger topped with BellaVitano whiskey cheese, kitchen pickle chips, grainy Dijon, lettuce, and tomato.

Route 66
45 W Liberty St, #2700, Lancaster
Locals can’t get enough of Route 66 and their out-of-this-world burgers. Their burgers are more of the flat, crispy-on-the-edges type that are ideal for stacking and layering with melted American cheese. They make a mean special sauce, then top the burger with the classics (lettuce, tomato, and onion). You’ll dig this uncomplicated, classic burger while visiting Downtown Lancaster.

Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm
3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird in Hand
Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm serves up a variety of burgers, but the Smokehouse Stacker is a crowd favorite. Loaded with smoked beef brisket, pulled pork, applewood-smoked bacon, coleslaw, dill pickles, and their signature White Horse sauce, it’s an over-the-top bite you won’t forget.