At Citronnelle, you’ll find a menu built around Lancaster’s farm-fresh produce and wild, sustainable seafood, prepared with French flair and global flavors. They are BYOB with a seasonal menu, so you’ll have different selections with each visit.
Location: 110 West Orange Street
What diners love: “I had Arctic Char special that was served with a sauce that was so subtle yet decadent and flavorful I left nothing on my plate and said out loud, ‘this is the best fish dish I have had in a long time.’” - TripAdvisor
Manor Buffet offers a wide variety of fresh seafood along with Asian, American, Italian, and Japanese dishes in an upscale all-you-can-eat setting. You can enjoy everything from sushi to steamed crab legs in one stop.
Location: 2090 Lincoln Hwy E
What diners love: “Had dinner here last week and it was excellent! So much seafood! Loved the clams on the half shell, the sushi, the shrimp and crab meatballs, spare ribs...everything was good.” - Google Reviews
You can find top-tier seafood, including pan-seared scallops, fresh Scottish salmon fillets, and jumbo lump crab cakes, all prepared with care and served alongside local produce and seasonal specialties at Greenfield Restaurant.
Location: 595 Greenfield Rd
What diners love: “The fish dishes are fresh with elegant sauces. Being in the heart of Lancaster farm land, the Greenfield is true farm to table, a very fine table at that.” - Yelp
Seafood lovers will find plenty to enjoy at Josephine’s, with dishes like Salmon Oscar, Alaskan Halibut, and Seared Hokkaido Scallops. Each is prepared from scratch with fresh, high-quality ingredients from imaginative chefs.
Location: 50 West Grant Street
What diners love: “My husband had the crabcake which was succulent, sweet, and with such great flavors and texture. I tried the halibut with fresh corn and tomatoes. Delicious flavors, well prepared.” - Google Review.
Juicy Crab Seafood & Steak features fresh, flavorful seafood like snow crab legs, sweet shrimp, and lobster tails, all prepared with your choice of spice and sauces. Their signature individual cooking bags add a fun, hands-on aspect to your seafood dinner.
Location: 1306 Lititz Pike
What diners love: “Best seafood spot in Lancaster! Seafood [boil] is a game-changer—spicy, buttery, and just the right kick.” - Google Reviews
Lancaster’s Fat Crab Café brings a taste of the beach with fresh seafood like live and steamed blue crabs, scallops, oysters, lobster, and more. Located inside Mr. Bill’s Fresh Seafood Market, it’s a casual spot to enjoy lunch or dinner, or grab some grub to go from the market.
Location: 430 Harrisburg Ave
What diners love: “If you're looking for good seafood in Lancaster, look no further! I highly recommend the hot lobster roll. It has a buttery roll stuffed with lobster meat that comes with a side of chips.” - Google Reviews
Looking for an all-you-can-eat experience? Sushi Heaven has fresh options, including specialty rolls like Shrimp Tempura and Volcano Roll, as well as classic favorites like California and Spicy Tuna rolls. Their menu also features hibachi dishes, sashimi, and tasty appetizers like Crab Rangoon and Kani Salad.
Location: 35 S. Willowdale Drive, Suite 801
What diners love: “By far the best bang for your buck. Reasonably priced and the best part is the sushi is actually good. I've had close to everything on the menu and I have no complaints.” - Google Reviews
River Trail Brewing in Marietta offers a creative twist on classic pub fare, with tons of standout seafood dishes such as firecracker shrimp, shrimp and mussel bowls, and blackened mahi mahi tacos. Their menu also features hearty options, like crab mac & cheese and jambalaya, which pair nicely with a cold beer.
Location: 40 E Front Street, Marietta
What diners love: “I had the chop salad with added Mahi - without a doubt the best salad I've had at a restaurant!” - Google Reviews
Kyma Seafood Grill in Stevens, PA, features coastal-inspired dishes like colossal crab cakes, oysters Rockefeller, and ancho chili-honey grilled salmon. Or you can enjoy The Dock, an open-air bar serving plenty of seafood and other American fare favorites for lunch.
Location: 1640 North Reading Road, Stevens
What diners love: “By far the best bang for your buck. Reasonably priced and the best part is the sushi is actually good. I've had close to everything on the menu and I have no complaints.” - Google Reviews
These spots are a little outside of Lancaster, but are all great seafood options to have on your radar if you’re coming in from out of town.
Dig into fresh‐caught seafood like halibut, branzino, jumbo shrimp, and King crab, all cooked over an open wood fire to bring out a deep, smoky flavor at Devon Seafood & Steak in Hershey. Their menu also features surf-and-turf combos, classic steaks, and seasonal sides.
Location: 27 W. Chocolate Ave., Hershey
What diners love: “Devon never disappoints! We had a great meal, good wines from a diverse wine list, and super attentive service. Highly recommend the mussels, sea scallops and crab cakes.” - TripAdvisor
The First Post features a menu with standout seafood options, including lump crab cakes, ahi tuna, and Faroe Island salmon. The menu also includes options like shrimp and scallop risotto or sesame-crusted tuna, giving diners a variety of coastal flavors to enjoy.
Location: 3691 E Market, York
What diners love: “Delicious and unique food options! The ambiance is really cool, and we had great service.” - Yelp
Rockfish Public House prides itself on fresh daily seafood, from raw oysters and grilled Chesapeake rockfish to colossal crab cakes and pan-seared scallops. It’s also known for its full raw bar, creative entrees, and drink selection.
Location: 110 N George St, York
What diners love: “We ate oysters on the half shell, shrimp and crab egg rolls, kale chips, and drinks! The oysters were outstanding, the shrimp crab egg rolls were to die for!” - Google Reviews
110 W. Orange St. Lancaster, PA 17603 (717) 208-6697
2090 Lincoln Hwy E. Lancaster, PA 17602 (717) 290-8181
595 Greenfield Road Lancaster, PA 17601 (717) 393-0668
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more
Where to See Santa Claus in Lancaster, PA
Santa Claus is coming to town! See the 2025 list of places to see Santa in Lancaster.
Lancaster County Gift Guide
Find the perfect gift for all those in your life, from the adventurer to those that appreciate a hand-made gift.
Top Drive-Thru Holiday Light Shows in Lancaster, PA
Drive through the most dazzling holiday light displays in and around Lancaster County, PA! From immersive 3‑mile LED drives to festive stadium shows and animated…
