Posted: 10/23/2023

Amish-Owned Restaurants in Lancaster County, PA

Explore Lancaster County and Pennsylvania Dutch foods, and much more, at these Amish-owned restaurants.

Traditional Amish food from Lancaster County PA

BrickHouse Coffee and Kitchen
53 Refton Road, Refton, PA 17568 | 717.806.8019

BrickHouse Coffee & Kitchen is located in the southern end of Lancaster county, in a charming building dating back to the mid-1800s. Enjoy delicious drinks, pastries, breakfast items such as french toast or omelets, and even lunch or dinner with signature sandwiches and more made-to-order with local ingredients!

Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Café
4040 Old Philadelphia Pike, Gordonville | 717.354.7988
The Lapp family has been creating delicious hand-crafted ice cream since 1975, but with their new location, there is even more to love! Visit the Creamery & Café location to enjoy a delicious grilled menu featuring locally raised beef, Lancaster County cheese and homemade bread to the already fan-favorite ice-cream choices! Open for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!

Hometown Kitchen
18 Furnace Rd, Quarryville | 717.806.5188

Have a delicious breakfast, lunch, or dinner with Hometown Kitchen! Offering an expansive menu with sandwiches, hot entrees, salads, and more prepared by Amish chefs, as well as a traditional Amish wedding meal on special every Friday!

Katie’s Kitchen

200 Hartman Bridge Rd, Ronks | 717.687.5333

Enjoy authentic Amish cooking for breakfast, lunch and dinner at Katie’s Kitchen. With homemade platters, sandwiches, burgers, and homemade desserts there’s something for everyone.

Explore other Amish-made foods!

Achenbach’s Pastry
375 E Main St, Leola | 717.656.6671

Head out to Leola for delicious Amish baked goods. A local favorite being the peanut butter iced long john’s! Known for not adding preservatives to their homemade baked goods, they can also ship items!

Bird-In-Hand Bake Shop
542 Gibbons Rd, Bird-in-Hand | 717.656.7947

Try homemade breads, pies, whoopie pies, shoofly pie, noodles, and more! You can also find locally made crafts, gifts, a picnic area, and a petting zoo on the property.

Down on the Farm Creamery
509 May Post Office Rd, Strasburg | 717.687.7540

Enjoy homemade ice cream, milk, cheese and more. Play on the playground, visit with the farm animals, and have some family fun!

Lapp Valley Farm Creamery
244 Mentzer Road, New Holland | 717.354.7988

Enjoy delicious handcrafted small batch ice cream, freshly made waffle cones, and homemade butter and milk. Pet the calves, see cows being milked, and enjoy the farm’s grounds. Lapp Valley Farm ice cream can also be found at the Green Dragon Farm Market, at Kitchen Kettle Village during the summer, and at Lapp Valley Creamery & Café on Old Philadelphia Pike.

Related Content

Missing Lancaster and all the wonderful food it has to offer? We’ve got your back! Follow the recipes below to bring a taste...

Read about these five chefs who are proud to serve delicious and memorable meals in Lancaster!

Check out some of the awesome places to stay and eat, things to do, and more to start planning your trip to Lancaster...

group of friends eating at restaurant

Tasty new spots to grab a bite to eat in Lancaster

a family rides in an Amish horse-drawn buggy through farmland on an Amish tour in Lancaster, PA

The Amish & Mennonite may look the same, but there are some notable differences!

Amish horse & buggy trotting along the road in Lancaster County, PA
Photo Credit: Discover Lancaster / Gabe McMullen

Visiting the Pennsylvania Amish in Lancaster County

A variety of fasnacht pastries in a white paper bag.

How many of these must-eats have you tried?